Living Long Lives in Genesis
Question
1) question on genesis:
i will just go verse by verse so you can see my thought process
1 – god begins creating the universe
2 – the earth is unformed, but there are waters??? (I can see this being poetic or symbolic)
3 – some form of light is made
4 – light is separated from darkness
5 – light is day, dark is night
6 – water is separated from water (waters from 1:2??)
7 – the sky (atmosphere is created)
8 – the expanse is called heaven
9 – dry land appears from waters … we know that land came before water, so how could this be?
10 – dry land is called earth
11 – plants come to fruition … we know that plants need the sun, so how did they grow??
12 – more vegetation
13 – evening / morning stuff
14 – the sun / other stars are created
2) questions on ages:
if the ancient hebrews (such as avraham) followed a solar calender, then how did they live so long? humans couldnt not have physically lived that long. this would naturally lead me to think they measured years differently, but the torah makes it seem like a solar calender is in place (genesis 1:14 for example)
Answers
There are several reasons for the gradual reduction in life span from Biblical times to the present.
God initially intended to grant people eternal life. According to Kabbalistic texts, if Adam and Eve had refrained from eating from the Tree of Knowledge until Shabbat, thereby exercising free will to perfect themselves, God would have given them to eat of the Tree of Life and then from the Tree of Knowledge. They would have obtained a level of spiritual excellence entitling them to live with full knowledge forever.
However, Adam and Eve transgressed the Will of God, bringing upon themselves the consequence of the warning, “But of the Tree of Knowledge of good and evil you shall not eat, for on the day that you eat thereof, you shall surely die”. This isn’t intended literally – they didn’t die on that day. Rather, it means that they brought upon themselves mortality.
Based on the verse, “For a thousand years in Your eyes are like a day that passed,” our Sages explain that man’s life span was limited to one of “God’s days” of one thousand years. According to this, Adam should have lived to be a thousand years old. Why does the verse assert, “Adam lived nine hundred and thirty years, and he died”? The Midrash explains that Adam, with his great spiritual insight, foresaw that King David was destined to die as an infant, so he contributed seventy years of his own life to David.
Later, as a result of further “misconduct”, man’s life span was shortened even more: “And the Lord said, Let My spirit not quarrel forever concerning man, because he is also flesh, and his days shall be a hundred and twenty years”. Rashi explains God’s intention: Behold My spirit is quarrelling within Me whether to destroy or to have mercy. Let this quarrel in My spirit not endure forever, rather since man is only flesh, and nevertheless he does not subordinate himself before Me, let him live no more than 120 years. Ibn Ezra (c. 1100, Spain) explains that life spans would gradually decrease, until the maximum will be around 120. (For example, Adam lived to 930, Shem – 600, Abraham – 175, Jacob – 147, Moses – 120.)
Finally, until the Flood, there were no extremes in seasons; the weather was always comfortable and temperate. After the Flood, God tells Noah that there will be constant seasonal changes. The Malbim (1800’s, Eastern Europe) explains that until the Flood the earth’s axis had no tilt relative to the sun. As a result of the flood, the earth’s axis tilted in relation to the sun. Thus, the earth’s climate changed drastically, resulting in a weakening of the human constitution and ability to withstand these constant changes in weather.
Best wishes from the AskTheRabbi.org Team